si tu, muy politica.
cad on 13 May 2007 | dallas & news
I usually don’t get political, so I’m not too good at this.
There were a lot of people voting yesterday here in the Dallas area. One particular hot topic in the news around Dallas is Ordinance 2903. To give you a quick summary, this Ordinance (which passed) says that anyone interested in renting/owning a home in the Farmers Branch area will have to submit proof of citizenship or immigration status.
I’m not from Farmers Branch, and honestly I don’t visit much either, but if it’s anything like Oak Cliff, I know I wouldn’t be the minority there. There was a debate on the radio on Friday afternoon between LULAC member and Farmers Branch resident, Luis de la Garza (no relation) and Farmers Branch City Councilman Tim O’Hare.
You can download the debate on iTunes (search for Ernie and Jay Interviews and KRLD), or you can go here for part I and here for part II. It’s about 40 minutes in length, but it’s really worth it if you want to listen to it.
Well, De La Garza bombed, badly. I wish the debate would have had a better prepared De La Garza or maybe even another representation for the con’s of the Ordinance. He guilelessly admitted on live radio to have not even read the Ordinance, meaning he did not truly know what it was about. He tried to debate something along the lines of, “and what about the children?” And O’Hare said, “The Ordinance clearly states that this does not pertain to children or senior citizens. Have you read the Ordinance?” De La Garza said, “No.”
Now, I understand that when faced with certain things that feel like a slap to your face and you despise the topic you want nothing to do with it. But if you’re going to a debate, you need to know your material. The best way to argue a subject is to research. Sob stories about coming to the United States and driving an expensive car and people thinking you’re a drug dealer because you’re brown and have a nice car, have nothing to do with the topic at hand. He got off the topic so many times.
At times he did make clear statements. But he needed, IMO, to stress how the passage of this would not help the illegal immigration issue here in the United States. Clearly it’s just a law made by a city who wants to throw out the poor and tear down some apartments to build other property to make money. But in the process, they’re kicking out the people who would probably help build this new property that will lift the value up of the city.
I know, from coming from a Mexican family, that a lot of these families will be fine. They will find a home, probably here in Oak Cliff, and it’s just a mountain that they will have to cross again. I doubt they’ll bow their heads in defeat, pack up their things, and go back to Mexico.
My problem with this law that passed is the hate that will come from it. I’ll be honest, to this day, I can’t recall ever being harassed or blamed or called names because of my skin color or because of where my parents are from. Yes, I’ve been racially profiled before. Sometimes even in Mexico, “Esta se cree MUY AMERICANA!” But it’s never been anything that made me cry myself to sleep. A lot of it probably has to do with the people i do and don’t hang around with, and the fact that I live where I’m not the minority. But maybe I just lucked out, because it’s the contrary on the news and everything I’ve come across especially when I worked with the government.
It’s unfortunate that many ignorant people without reading about laws or considering other people’s feelings and seeing them as “human” will hate because of laws as such. They will call people names, one thing will lead to another, and next thing you know, it’s a huge deal on the news. Which just causes more hate and this never ending cycle we’ve all seen in the United States just continues because we can’t seem to live on the same block without respecting one another and each other’s opinions.
I am not for illegal immigration. Not because I hate Mexicans or any other race, but because I’ve seen the really bad side of it, pictures, read stories and cried at how bad the system is. But just because I’m against illegal immigration, it doesnt mean it doesnt exist. It’s like drugs. It’s there. People use them, people sell them, people kill people over them. This can of worms is too huge to control now and everyone is going in different directions that I doubt it will ever be cleaned up.
This law passing in Farmers Branch is not even a dent. They got what they wanted, and like I said, I wish they had better representation on that debate on the radio because Luis really put his foot in his mouth a couple of times and all my mom and I could do was sigh and nod our heads. But the law passed, and illegal immigrants are still here, and they’ll forever be here. Just maybe they’re my neighbors, not theirs.
And I’m okay with that. Like I said. . .it’s home. It’s where I’m NEVER going to be the minority.
I wonder if going now to Farmers Branch I’ll be pulled over and asked to show proof of citizenship. I’ll let you know if that happens. I think I’m going to start to go to the gym that’s over there instead of the one closer to me. ![]()

current tuneage. . . Sara Bareilles – Love Song
msondo on 13 May 2007 at 11:47 pm #
It’s times like this I am glad I don’t live there anymore.
Don’t get me wrong, I freaking love Dallas… it’s an amazing city, but it’s surrounded by a ton of crappy suburbs with bad vibes.
I agree with you and say I am against this law because it will inevitably bring more hate. I can already sense it. Mexicans, for the most part, were not really targeted as much by hate speech. Lately, however, I see tons of anti-Mexican rhetoric. More and more I feel like I need to justify my own existence here. Why should I? My family has lived in Dallas for several generations, and parts of my family have been in Texas as far back as I can trace. If anybody should really feel like they belong here then my family should, but I am perceiving increased hostility and get the feeling that more people see me and think I don’t belong.
Part of the money that funded this came from a t-shirt fundraiser. The t-shirts said something like “Welcome to America, now please speak English.” The part of my family that is solidly Tejano has always spoken Spanish. In fact, my generation was the first to learn English first. That may be surprising to some people but Texas was once actually part of Mexico, and Spanish was a dominant language (and still mostly is.) Why do you think Tejano music is primarily sung in Spanish? To me, the shirts and the overall attitudes of the people peddling them are extremely hostile. My family is bilingual and very proud of their culture. In fact, most of the younger generation have maintained our love and knowledge of Spanish despite the fact that we had to make an extra effort to study it. The mayor of Farmer’s Branch actually wanted to ban all foreign language literature from the local library. What does this say about the people there? To me, it shows a high level of ignorance and intellectual mediocrity.
I’m typically for respecting laws but I believe laws should be respected only when the laws are respectable. Look at the economic history of Mexico, in particular the effects of NAFTA on Mexican people. Market dumping in sectors such as maize, wheat, and legumes by US corporations helped force millions of Mexican farmers off of their land. You can compare the graphs of crashing corn prices and farm foreclosures and see a strong relationship between DHS estimates of illegals entering the country. It’s legal for us to totally fuck over the Mexican economy, take their land and natural resources, leave them with nothing… and yet expect them to remain idle? Fuck that. If our government and corproations are going to take whatever they want without any regard to the common Mexican, I think letting them come here and take what they want is the very least we can offer. Millions are here. More will come. There will be tons of us here… who knows, we may become the majority some day? As hard as we tend to work, it’ll only be a matter of time until we take over.
What are people afraid of? In a few generations, all of those immigrants will be just like us and the rest of the people who have been here for a while… moderately successful, influential, and part of the machine we all love and hate.
msondo on 14 May 2007 at 12:55 am #
Per the request of Claudia, I sat down and listened and noticed a couple of things… and yes, I have been following this via news and magazine articles.
O’hare mentions that immigration was supposedly always an issue for FB residents. Well, in 2006 a citizen task force was setup with 60 FB residents to have them voice key issues with the city. Illegal immigration, mexicans, etc. were never mentioned. In fact, it was only until an online group called Farmers Branch Citizens Group (O’hare is a key member) emerged that this became an issue. This is per Liz Biss (a member of the task force) and was published in this month’s D Magazine.
O’hara also blames illegal immigrants for his failings in the real estate market. Aside from his own mediocre command of financial matters, the strain on home values can best be attributed to the lagging housing market. A big reason for the lagging housing market is the subprime loan market, which, ironically is a major sponsor of conservative talk radio (the people that organized the “speak English” t-shirt campaign.) You can also attribute it to other things such as a weak dollar (to other currencies such as the Euro… which has grown significantly thanks to open markets and a highly educated and motivated population that on-average speaks more than one language and thus is able to better compete on a global scale.)
O’hara also claimed that legal fees will supposedly never go beyond the $100k deductible per the legal insurance FB has invested in. So, essentially you are spending $100k (not factoring the other fees that the insurance will not cover, namely time and beaurocratic muscle necessary to enforce and maintain this) to collect fines of $500. These will be really hard to prove because all an illegal has to do is doctor up some document that purports a legal status here. If a landlord is required to ask for proof of citizenship, and they are shown a false greencard… how can the landlord be expected to know enough about immigration documents to know which is fake and which is real? It sounds like a stupid move, economically speaking.
De la Garza is passionate but he was definitely the wrong person to represent the argument.
Julissa on 14 May 2007 at 10:31 am #
I find this ordinance completely insulting. Even more insulting is the LULAC representative, Luis de la Garza, for not reading before debating.